Old Town Real Estate

Old Town Real Estate

Welcome to Old Town, a charming subdivision nestled in the heart of Colorado, where historic charm meets modern living. This picturesque community, known for its vibrant atmosphere and rich history, offers residents a unique blend of quaint streets, beautifully preserved architecture, and an inviting sense of belonging.

Old Town is a haven for those who appreciate a walkable lifestyle, with tree-lined sidewalks that lead to an array of local boutiques, coffee shops, and eateries. The neighborhood is brimming with character, featuring Victorian-style homes and cozy cottages that tell stories of the past while providing all the comforts of contemporary living. Here, you can enjoy leisurely strolls through scenic parks, participate in community events, or simply soak in the stunning views of the Rocky Mountains.

Families will find Old Town particularly appealing, thanks to its proximity to top-rated schools and recreational facilities. The community is designed with families in mind, offering playgrounds, sports fields, and safe spaces for children to play and explore. Additionally, the sense of community is palpable, with friendly neighbors and local gatherings that foster connections and friendships.

For those who crave adventure, Old Town is conveniently located near numerous hiking and biking trails, as well as access to winter sports in the nearby mountains. Whether you’re looking for a peaceful retreat or an active lifestyle, Old Town provides the perfect backdrop for your next chapter.

Come discover the charm of Old Town, where every day feels like a step back in time, but with all the conveniences of modern living right at your fingertips. Your dream home awaits in this delightful Colorado community!

Newest Listings in Old Town

629 Mathews St, Fort Collins
$830,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ IR1072294 MLS
There's something special about living in Old Town Fort Collins, and this 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home puts you right in the heart of it! Enjoy morning walks to your favorite coffee shop, dinner with friends, or an afternoon exploring the shops and restaurants that make Old Town such a desirable place to live. The home is full of character, with original hardwood floors, beadboard accents throughout, and the charm you'd expect from an established Old Town property. Granite kitchen countertops, updated lighting, and energy-efficient windows add modern touches while maintaining the home's original appeal. Even better, the sellers have made significant investments in the home's major systems, including a premium heating and cooling system with a high-efficiency heat pump and whole-home humidifier (2025), upgraded electrical service and panel (2026), and a Class 4 impact-resistant roof (2019). Outside, mature trees, peekaboo mountain views, and established landscaping create a beautiful setting with apple and plum trees, berry bushes, colorful perennials, and a dedicated pollinator garden. A thoughtfully designed sprinkler and drip irrigation system makes caring for the yard that much easier. The detached garage offers approximately 600 square feet of additional space, perfect for storage, hobbies, or exploring future possibilities. With convenient parking, major system updates, and easy access to everything Old Town has to offer, this home gives you all the character of an older property with the added confidence of thoughtful, valuable improvements.

629 Mathews St, Fort Collins

Courtesy of RE/MAX Alliance-Loveland . 9704130689

1208 W Mountain Ave, Fort Collins
$2,100,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ IR1070932 MLS
Exceptional Historic Design on Iconic Mountain Avenue From the expansive front porch, the character is immediate. Step inside to original wood floors, rich woodwork and details that simply cannot be replicated today. At the heart of the home, a stunning custom Montezuma Fuller curved staircase serves as an architectural centerpiece and a reminder of the artistry with which this home was built. Gracious living and dining spaces retain their historic integrity, while a dedicated main-level office overlooking Mountain Avenue offers a front-row seat to one of Old Town's most beloved streets - watch the neighborhood pass by or catch the trolley rolling past your window. The beautifully updated kitchen brings a decidedly modern element to the home, with high-end appliances, generous workspace and room for casual dining. Just beyond, the living space spills naturally outdoors onto an expansive deck and gorgeously landscaped backyard, creating an incredible setting for entertaining, long dinners with friends or simply spending a quiet afternoon under the mature trees. Extensive recent landscaping improvements, including new cedar fencing, further enhance this special outdoor setting. The carriage house offers an additional 1125 sq ft - a fantastic extension of the property with a bar and casual hangout/flex space on the main level and a private guest suite upstairs. With recently added heating and air conditioning, updated flooring, lighting and a solid wood entry door, it offers incredible flexibility for guests, work, entertaining or simply having another place to retreat. Historic integrity. Exceptional craftsmanship. Elevated design. And a front-row seat to life on Mountain Avenue. This is Old Town Fort Collins at its very best.

1208 W Mountain Ave, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Group Harmony . 9704811277

195 Briggs St, Erie
$849,999
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2287410 MLS
Conveniently positioned on a corner quarter-acre lot along Briggs Street, Old Town Erie's main corridor, this property isn't just a home. It's a multi-revenue platform in one of Colorado's fastest-growing communities, zoned Neighborhood Mixed-Use (NMU) & ready to work as hard as you do. The numbers speak first: the two-story unit is already a proven Airbnb performer, averaging $25K gross annually. That's day-one cash flow w/ room to grow as Erie's popularity continues its upward trajectory. The home's natural division into two independent living spaces each w/ its own kitchen & full bath gives you the flexibility to run dual short-term rentals, a long-term tenant alongside an owner-occupied unit, or a live-work arrangement. But the real story here is the NMU zoning allowing home business, professional office, boutique retail, or rental units, As Old Town Erie continues to attract traffic, new residents, & commercial investment, the upside potential of this zoning only increases. An oversized 28x30 garage with 12-foot walls, insulation, evaporative cooling, & rough-in plumbing is primed for conversion — a future ADU, workshop income, personal automotive work/storage, or premium storage rental are all options. 14x18 greenhouse with a 12-foot peak ceiling adds yet another revenue or lifestyle angle. Ample off-street & side street parking ensures you always have a place to park. The one-story side of the home was completely gutted and renovated, & is adaptive-friendly; it even has a heated floor in the bathroom. The 2-story side has a huge kitchen, wood-burning stove & vaulted ceilings. Walk to shops, restaurants, schools, & medical facilities. Watch the community events fill Briggs Street. Then consider: properties w/ this zoning, this footprint, this income history, & this location rarely come available. When they do, they don't last. This is Old Town Erie's version of a value-add opportunity. The foundation is already built — the next chapter is yours to write.

195 Briggs St, Erie

Courtesy of RE/MAX Elevate . 720-375-1255

817 Whedbee St, Fort Collins
$679,000
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1067842 MLS
2 HOUSES on a large 0.22 acre lot!!!! 1942 sq ft home with 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms PLUS fully permitted 817 sq ft, 2 beds and 1 bath ABU (Accessory Building Unit) built in 2003 with alley access. This is a rare opportunity in the heart of Old Town Fort Collins! Situated on a 0.22 acre lot, 817 Whedbee offers outstanding potential for the right buyer with a vision. The main home facing Whedbee is a 2 story with a basement and in need of a full remodel, but the extended value lies in the prime location, lot size, and permitted accessory building unit (ABU) at the rear of the lot with alley access. The possibilities for this property are substantial. Fully renovated homes in the surrounding neighborhood are commonly valued in the $1.5M-$1.8M range. The accessory building unit offers flexibility for a variety of potential uses, including living on-site while renovating or rebuilding the main home (buyer to verify all uses and regulations with the City of Fort Collins). Whether you're looking to renovate, expand, invest, or build your dream Old Town home - create something truly special in one of Fort Collins' most sought-after neighborhoods. Property is being sold AS-IS. Pre-inspected - the report is available upon request. Large lots like this in Old Town are increasingly difficult to find - bring your vision and unlock the potential of this exceptional property.

817 Whedbee St, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Grey Rock Realty . 9706921724

364 Main St, Erie
$599,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 5335048 MLS
Welcome to 364 Main Street, a beautifully preserved 1966 brick ranch in the heart of Old Town Erie. With 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and over 2,500 square feet of single-level living, this home offers the space you are looking for without sacrificing character. Solid brick construction gives this home the kind of durability and timeless curb appeal that's hard to find in newer homes. Inside, original mid-century details have been lovingly preserved — think classic architectural lines, warm wood accents, and the kind of craftsmanship that defined the era. It's a rare opportunity to own a piece of Erie's history while enjoying the comfort of a spacious, updated-feeling floor plan. This home has a new roof, new central air conditioning and furnace, newer hot water heater, cozy wood burning fireplace, updated windows, a full finished basement and so many original charming details. The 10,000 sq ft lot with alley access has all the space you need. The location is unbeatable: just steps from Old Town Erie's beloved restaurants, coffee shops, and local businesses. Just steps to Erie Middle School and Erie Elementary School. Walk to dinner, grab a coffee, visit the dog park or take in a community event — all without leaving your neighborhood. Whether you're drawn to the mid-century architecture, the walkable Main Street lifestyle, or the rare combination of space and character, 364 Main Street is a special find in one of Erie's most sought-after pockets. No metro tax, no HOA.

364 Main St, Erie

Courtesy of RE/MAX Elevate . 720-375-1255

Start Your Search


The content relating to real estate for sale in this Web site comes in part from the Internet Data eXchange (“IDX”) program of METROLIST, INC., DBA RECOLORADO® Real estate listings held by brokers other than eXp Realty are marked with the IDX Logo. This information is being provided for the consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose. All information subject to change and should be independently verified. IDX Terms and Conditions

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!