Fort Collins Homes with Rustic Style

Welcome to Fort Collins, Colorado – a vibrant city nestled at the foothills of the Rocky Mountains in Larimer County. Known for its breathtaking natural beauty, Fort Collins offers a unique blend of urban charm and outdoor adventure. With a rich history and a thriving arts scene, this city is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. Enjoy the vibrant downtown area filled with local breweries, eclectic shops, and a variety of dining options that cater to every palate. For outdoor enthusiasts, the nearby Horsetooth Reservoir and Cache la Poudre River provide endless opportunities for hiking, biking, fishing, and kayaking.

If you’re captivated by the rustic charm of homes that echo the spirit of the Colorado landscape, Fort Collins has a fantastic selection of rustic-style properties. These homes often feature natural materials like wood and stone, large porches, and expansive windows that invite the stunning mountain views indoors. Imagine cozy evenings by a stone fireplace or entertaining friends on a spacious deck surrounded by the beauty of nature.

Rustic homes in Fort Collins are not just structures; they are a lifestyle choice that embraces the warmth of nature while providing modern comforts. Many of these residences are located in peaceful neighborhoods, blending seamlessly with the picturesque environment. Whether you’re seeking a quaint cabin or a sprawling ranch-style home, Fort Collins offers a variety of rustic properties that cater to your desire for a serene, nature-inspired lifestyle. Come explore the charm of Fort Collins and find your dream home today!

Newest Fort Collins Homes with Rustic Style

$950,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1068191 MLS

A rare opportunity to own a half-acre in town. Situated on an expansive 26,500-square-foot lot, 1505 S Shields offers a unique combination of move-in-ready living and long-term potential.Recent improvements include fresh interior paint, refinished hardwood floors, new carpeting in the bedrooms, basement and upper living room, updated lighting and bathrooms, a new roof in 2023, solar panels, heat pumps, and added interior insulation-all completed within the past five years.The home features three spacious bedrooms, three bathrooms, a large finished basement with separate exterior access, and a sun-filled second-story living room.Ready for its next chapter, the property offers room to imagine an addition, carriage house, urban farm, multifamily use, or an entirely new vision. There may also be an opportunity to assemble additional neighboring parcels. Consult the agent for information regarding other properties currently available.Emily Heinz: A rare opportunity to own a half-acre in town. Situated on an expansive 26,500-square-foot lot, 1505 S Shields offers a unique combination of move-in-ready living and long-term potential.Recent improvements include fresh interior paint, refinished hardwood floors, new carpeting in the bedrooms, basement and upper living room, updated lighting and bathrooms, a new roof in 2023, 7.2 kw/h solar panels in 2024, a new heat pump, and added interior insulation-all completed within the past five years.The home features three spacious bedrooms, three bathrooms, a large finished basement with separate exterior access, and a sun-filled second-story living room.Ready for its next chapter, the property offers room to imagine an addition, carriage house, urban farm, multifamily use, or an entirely new vision. There may also be an opportunity to assemble additional neighboring parcels. Consult the agent for information regarding other properties currently available.

1505 S Shields Street, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Downtown Real Estate Brokers . 9709889367

$434,415

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1066817 MLS

MOVE-IN READY. Farmhouse elevation Magnolia plan by Hartford Homes in Bloom in Fort Collins. New construction cottage. Open floor plan, two story. Kitchen w/ island. Powder bath on main level. Eucalyptus painted maple cabinetry. Quartz countertops. Vinyl plank flooring and carpet. S.s. dishwasher, fridge, microwave, range included. Second level has 2 bedrooms and laundry w/ Washer & dryer included. Central a/c. Garage door opener. Active Radon. Fenced yard w/ landscaping included (artificial turf in backyard). Usage of a detached garage w/ different legal address located at 287 FLOURISH LN 108 w/ EV Charger. There is a $75 annual non-potable water fee to be paid to metro district. Bloom in Fort Collins has future plans for a resort-style pool, parks, trails, and future retail and dining. PHOTOS FROM ACTUAL HOME. ASK ABOUT CURRENT LENDER OR CASH BUYER INCENTIVES. MOVE IN READY!!

3254 Crusader Street, Fort Collins

Courtesy of RE/MAX Alliance-FTC South . 9702263990

$1,125,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ IR1066751 MLS

Welcome to 400 Ridgewood Ct-a rare Fort Collins horse property and hobby farm sited just minutes from Old Town, offering the space, privacy, and productive land that's nearly impossible to find this close to town.Custom-built by high-quality regional builder Bob Heath of Heath Construction and designed as an energy-efficient "Earth House," the home pairs real character with everyday comfort. White oak, wire-brushed hardwood floors, soaring wood-beam ceilings, and hand-stitched stonework signal craftsmanship at every turn. A beautifully renovated primary suite anchors the home, while a gas fireplace and a wood-burning stove make for warm, inviting Colorado evenings.The equestrian setup is ready to go: a 3-stall barn, riding arena, corrals, automatic waterer, and irrigated pasture-built for horses or small-scale farming.The grounds are fully established for a homestead lifestyle. A 60x30 fenced organic garden with drip irrigation is already planted and will produce from late summer into fall-melons, tomatoes, greens, beans, squash, pumpkins, and sunflowers. A chicken coop and run, 25+ mature trees, and established fruit production-including apple trees carrying hundreds of apples ready to pick this fall-bring both beauty and function. It's a property that gives back as much as you put into it, with room to expand the operation however you see fit.Beyond the work, there's room to simply enjoy it all. Unwind in the cedar sauna, gather friends on the stone patio, and take in the quiet of your own working land under the Front Range sky-all just minutes from town and top-rated schools.Few properties bring this much together-acreage, a custom home, a turnkey equestrian setup, and a fully producing homestead-which makes 400 Ridgewood Ct a genuinely rare value for a buyer who wants it all without giving up the convenience of being close to everything Fort Collins offers.

400 Ridgewood Court, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Compass - Boulder . 9705410571

$630,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ IR1065794 MLS

*SHORT SALE - REHAB OPPORTUNITY* Here's a project with a setting that's hard to duplicate. This 2.5-acre lakefront property has lake views, usable acreage, an oversized attached garage and a 1,064 SF powered shop-all in a great NoCo location. This is more than a cosmetic fixer and the price reflects the work ahead. For buyers comfortable with a renovation the combination of acreage, lakefront setting, shop space and existing home creates an interesting value-add opportunity that can't be duplicated elsewhere. Inside, the home has vaulted ceilings, great natural light, skylights and generous living spaces with multiple doors leading outside. The kitchen has been updated w solid-surface counters, SS appliances, a 5-burner gas range and oversized peninsula. The finished garden-level basement adds a large flex area, additional nonconforming bedroom, full bath, storage and exterior access. Outside, the 2.5 acres offer room for horses, a hobby farm, equipment and more. The detached 1,064 SF shop has a concrete floor and separate sub-panel, giving the property useful workspace and storage beyond the oversized attached garage. There is real work to take on here, but also features that are difficult to add later: land, lake views, no HOA and a substantial shop. Bring your contractor and take a look at what this property could become. SHORT SALE - Bank approval and adequate time flexibility required. Property is being sold AS-IS. Note - No HOA but there are Covenants recorded (See Documents).

734 Victoria Drive, Fort Collins

Courtesy of C3 Real Estate Solutions, LLC . 9704604167

$990,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1064594 MLS

This renovated farmhouse offers a fresh opportunity on 2 acres. The home blends original farmhouse character with extensive modern updates and flexible living space. The upstairs primary suite provides a spacious retreat, while a main-level bedroom with ensuite bath offers flexibility for guests, multigenerational living, or a home office. The renovated kitchen features custom European-style cabinetry, with updated bathrooms, flooring, paint, electrical, plumbing, tankless water heater, furnace/AC units, and new appliances. Two full-size washer and dryer sets add convenience. Outside, you'll find new siding, roof, windows, doors, patios, and exterior paint, along with owned solar panels and a Tesla EV charger. The 2-acre property also includes a barn, studio, non-potable water access for irrigation or animals, garden and animal space, and an extensive custom irrigation system designed with water conservation in mind. With room for outdoor projects, gardening, animals, entertaining, or simply enjoying the acreage, this property offers a rural setting with convenient access to Fort Collins, Wellington, Laramie, and Cheyenne. Basic 1-year First American Home Warranty is being offered by the Seller's Agent.

444 E County Road 68, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Real . 9702371445

$1,070,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1063470 MLS

**OPEN HOUSE. FRI Sept 4. 5-8PM.** Simply charming Queen Anne Victorian farmhouse that's ideal for today's work-from-home lifestyle. Its flexibility allows for changes that time brings. Thoughtfully designed with multiple workspaces, private offices, & multi-generational living in mind, this stunning home blends timeless 1910 character with modern comfort in the heart of Old Town. Situated on a mature landscaped, fully fenced 0.22-acre corner double lot, the property offers a unique sense of tranquility just blocks from Old Town's restaurants, shops, & vibrant energy. The rare original limestone sidewalk & welcoming covered front porch lead inside, where hardwood floors connect the central family room to a stunning open dining-kitchen area. Expertly remodeled by HighCraft, the kitchen features custom shaker cabinetry, soapstone countertops, & period-appropriate fixtures that honor the home's heritage. HighCraft connected the detached studio to the main home, creating a versatile flex space that now includes a private study, 3/4 bath, large rec-room with a built-in Murphy bed, library shelving, & multiple closets. It is perfect for a home office, music / creative studio, or hosting guests. Choose your primary suite: the cozy yet spacious upstairs retreat with a walk-in closet, served by a stunning Belle Epoque-inspired bath featuring a clawfoot soaking tub, spacious tiled shower, & marble countertops, or the expansive main-level suite with vaulted ceilings, fireplace, 3/4 bath & French doors opening to the patio, making it equally suited as a bedroom, executive office, or larger family area. The 3rd bedroom is also located on the upper level. Enjoy the covered front porch, private patio, backyard deck, & expansive lawn. Completing the property are an attached 2-car garage with attic storage (13'x18'x9'), an electric-gated driveway, & an oversized bike shed/studio/shop. A rare opportunity to own a beautifully restored piece of Ft Collins history.

301 N Whitcomb Street, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Grey Rock Realty . 9706921724

$739,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1062792 MLS

Come live the homestead dream! This farmhouse-style property on approximately 2.3 acres with open zoning, offers flexibility for business use, hobby farming, or just good ole' country living. This property includes not one, not two but THREE detached garage/shop outbuildings. The two large detached garage/shop buildings are approximately 864 square feet each, one of which is heated and an additional detached garage of approximately 572 square feet! But wait, there's more... Multiple smaller outbuildings including sheds and a chicken coop make this the ideal setup for a workshop, small business, or storage for work trucks, trailers, RVs (including a dump station on site), and recreational vehicles, with ample space for animals and gardening. This home offers 1,788 finished square feet on one level with 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, plus an office, a functional kitchen and dining area, spacious living room, and dedicated laundry/mudroom. Heated by hot water baseboard heat and cooled with a mini-split system and ceiling fans. Recent updates include all new interior paint throughout including cabinets and doors, updated flooring in select areas, remodeled laundry room with new cabinetry and butcher block countertops, updated lighting and ceiling fans, new blinds, and a refreshed kitchen with stainless steel appliances and added shelving. The secondary bathroom was updated with a new tub and tile and the roof was replaced in 2022. The Open zoning and usable acreage provides room to operate, expand, and customize to fit a variety of needs and the updated and totally move-in ready home makes this one incredible opportunity!

4829 E County Road 54, Fort Collins

Courtesy of C3 Real Estate Solutions, LLC . 9706852441

$4,100,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ IR1058235 MLS

A Rare Organic Homestead - Grounded in Self-Reliance and Natural Living. This is not just a property. It is a living, breathing testament to 42 years of intentional, sustainable stewardship - a fully operational organic homestead where the soil is rich, the systems are proven, and true self-sufficiency is not a goal, but a reality. Set on 2.75 irrigated acres fed by historic senior water rights, this remarkable estate offers everything the modern homesteader dreams of: (1) greenhouse + (2) hoop houses, (9) coops for raising chickens, ducks, and turkeys + netted enclosures, duck pond, a dedicated grain room, root cellar, hops vines, grape vines, and over 100 mature trees including an abundance of fruit varieties. Three ponds - two field ponds and a koi pond - add both function and tranquility to the landscape. Kitchen herb, cottage, vegetable, and moon gardens complete the growing sanctuary. A 2,700 SF heated garage/shop with 11' ceilings, commercial-grade True refrigeration and freezers, five chest freezers, and professional poultry processing equipment makes harvesting and preservation seamless. All farming equipment is negotiable. Inside, the home reflects the same quality and care. Hand-scraped black walnut floors, exposed wood beams, tongue-and-groove walls, and a real stone fireplace with Vermont Casting Wood Stove create warmth and character. The kitchen was thoughtfully remodeled with quartz counters, a leathered marble island, and ceramic tile. Primary bathroom remodeled in 2011. Laundry room updated in 2013 and guest bathroom on second level updated in 2024. The community enhances the lifestyle further, with neighborhood bridle paths, a shared horse arena, and a park with large pond - a natural extension of the rural, wide-open spirit this property embodies. Properties like this come along once in a lifetime - and rarely to those who are ready for them.

500 Apple Blossom Lane, Fort Collins

Courtesy of C3 Real Estate Solutions, LLC . 9706727212

$2,250,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ IR1057887 MLS

** Seller Financing with Negotiable Interest Rate is Available!! ** It's all about the country lifestyle and business opportunities on this incredible property with a charming multi-generational home and valuable water rights in south Fort Collins! Set on nearly 9 acres just outside city limits, this rare gem is known to many locals as "Something From The Farm." It's a Larimer County landmark, with so much to offer! The exceptional farmhouse with over 4,200 square feet features 6 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms, thoughtfully designed with a separate apartment for multi-generational living with comfort and privacy. Inspired by classic farmhouse design, the home is filled with natural light and showcases exposed beam ceilings, warm cedar accents, a brick fireplace, and a bright sunroom just off the kitchen-ideal for year-round enjoyment and entertaining. A rare collection of outbuildings adds exceptional versatility, including a USDA-certified organic greenhouse, enchanting farm stand, a two-car garage with dual studio or workshop spaces, and a large shop complete with a vehicle lift. The land is beautifully maintained with mature apricot and apple trees, along with younger peach and cherry trees, offering both charm and seasonal harvests. In years past - a popular produce stand provided locals with fresh garden goods. In recent years, the Fall pumpkin patch generating a six-figure annual income with hayrides drew even larger crowds. The grounds have also hosted multiple weddings, featuring a dedicated ceremony altar and a spacious, level area ideal for tents, dining, and events.

8020 S Timberline Road, Fort Collins

Courtesy of Group Mulberry . 9702372752

$899,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2141536 MLS

Builder Incentive of up to 6% when using preferred lender could provide approx. $50K towards allowable closing costs/prepaids and rate buy down. This can save you hundreds of dollars each month! This Trumark Homes Plan 3 at Kitchel Lake features a 4-car tandem garage off the front of the home with a farmhouse elevation style. This expansive two-story plan offers 2,768 Sq. Ft. of living space. Beyond the entry hall is the gourmet kitchen featuring 42" deluxe white shaker cabinetry with soft close features, quartz countertops with tile backsplash, Kitchen Aid stainless steel appliance package with a 5-burner gas cooktop, a convection oven, a built-in microwave, and a dishwasher. The kitchen conveniently connects to the pocket office and the covered outdoor room. Upstairs, you'll find a welcoming bonus room for reading, tv watching, gaming or hobbies. The two secondary bedrooms are connected by an ensuite bathroom with dual sinks. Down the hall, the primary suite offers a luxurious, spa-like bathroom with a walk-in shower and an expansive walk-in closet. This home features the Autumn Plus design finish package with extensive luxury vinyl plank flooring, luxurious carpet in bedrooms, contemporary bath fixtures, a tankless water heater, air conditioning, and an unfinished basement for future expansion. Best of all, this home backs to open space!

1295 Weller Street, Fort Collins

Courtesy of The Group Inc - Harmony . kathy@kathybeck.com,970-213-8475

Start Your Search

The content relating to real estate for sale in this Web site comes in part from the Internet Data eXchange (“IDX”) program of METROLIST, INC., DBA RECOLORADO® Real estate listings held by brokers other than eXp Realty are marked with the IDX Logo. This information is being provided for the consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose. All information subject to change and should be independently verified. IDX Terms and Conditions